TUFL Cookie Jars
Freshly baked, perfectly portioned, and packed with flavor.
TUFL Cookie Jars are filled with 6 soft, homemade cookies made in small batches and packed into our signature jars.
Choose your favorite flavor and treat yourself-or somebody you love-to a jar made for satisfying that sweet tooth.
Cookie Jars are offered during a 3-week preorder period. Once the preorder window closes, please allow up to 14 days for order preparation, baking, packaging, and processing.
Orders will begin shipping following the processing period, typically between days 15–19. To help maintain freshness and reduce the chance of packages sitting in transit over the weekend, orders are shipped Monday through Wednesday only.
Once your order has shipped, you will receive a shipping confirmation with tracking information. Please allow up to 24 hours for tracking information to update.
All Cookie Jar orders are shipped via UPS 2-Day shipping to help maintain freshness and minimize the amount of time your cookies spend in transit. Shipping rates are calculated at checkout based on the customer’s shipping address and order details.
Please note that days 15–19 refer to our shipping window, not your guaranteed delivery date. Once your package has been transferred to UPS, transit and delivery times are determined by the carrier and may be affected by weather, holidays, service interruptions, or other carrier-related delays.
To further protect the freshness of your cookies, packages are shipped Monday through Wednesday only. Orders will not be shipped Thursday through Sunday to reduce the possibility of packages remaining in transit over the weekend.
Customers are responsible for monitoring their tracking information and making arrangements to receive their package promptly upon delivery.
Freshness & Storage
For the best experience, enjoy your Cookie Jars within 2 days when stored at room temperature. Want to save them for later? Simply place your cookies in the freezer, where they can be stored for up to 2 months.
Warming Instructions
For that fresh-from-the-oven experience, remove the parchment square from the bottom of the cookie before warming.
Microwave: Heat for 8–10 seconds.
Oven or Air Fryer: Heat at 330°F for approximately 2 minutes.
Heating times may vary by appliance, so warm carefully and allow the cookie to cool slightly before enjoying.
TUFL Sweets Library products are prepared in a kitchen where common food allergens may be present, including wheat, milk, eggs, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, and gluten.
While care is taken during preparation, we cannot guarantee that any product is completely free from allergens or cross-contact. Customers with food allergies or dietary restrictions are responsible for reviewing product ingredients before placing an order.
Ingredient and allergen information is provided for each Cookie Jar flavor when applicable. If you have questions regarding the ingredients in a particular flavor, please contact us before placing your order.
Due to the perishable nature of our Cookie Jars, all sales are final. We do not accept returns or exchanges.
Orders may be canceled only while the preorder window is still open. Once the preorder period has closed and order preparation has begun, cancellations, changes, and refunds will not be accepted.
If there is an issue with your order upon arrival, please contact us within 24 hours of delivery so we can review the issue. Photos of the product and packaging will be required.